back to top
Sunday, December 8, 2024
HomeHOTEL REVIEWSHyattHyatt Place Times Square: Why So Rude?

Hyatt Place Times Square: Why So Rude?

Hyatt Place Times Square is part of the TPOL in NYC Trip Report.


I can’t tell you how many hotels I have stayed at in NYC. The worst one was Element (see Great Service, Bad Experience). The most overrated was the Park Hyatt (see Park Hyatt New York: Consistently Inconsistent). The rudest was the Hyatt Place Times Square.

While a building cannot be rude, those that work in it sure can be. Here’s what happened:

I took an early flight from Puerto Rico which arrived in NYC at 9:28AM. After enduring the AirTrain (see JFK AirTrain: Why Mess with Uber to Manhattan?) and the subway, it was 11AM when I arrived at the hotel. The place was a zoo. The lobby looked more like a bus station than a hotel. The queue for the front desk was long with many impatient guests. When it was finally my turn to check-in, a woman frantically jumped in front of me asking for a new room key since she had a taxi waiting. The lady at the front desk looked at her with scorn and said that she would have to get back in line. The woman pleaded for a room key. The attendant again directed her to the line. Sympathetic, I said that it was fine to give her a new room key.

My generosity was lost on the employee. She barely greeted me and only spoke to me to tell me that my room was not ready. I asked if she knew when it would be ready. She told me that normal check-in is at 3PM. She then asked for my phone number and told me that they would call when the room was ready.

As an Explorist, I don’t expect much from my status, though I have been granted access to my room many early mornings. In this case, it was obvious that the staff was overwhelmed and that the hotel was at capacity. How else can they justify charging $650 for one night at a Hyatt Place? Instead of waiting in the DMV lobby, I went to look for coffee. I made the mistake of going to Pret A Manger and paying $5.18 for a double espresso. For that price, I could have gone to my favorite coffee place in the City, Felix Roasting (see Best Java in NYC).

I didn’t make the most of the extortionate coffee price. Though I loitered in the cafe until 1:30PM, I was too tired to ask for the Wi-Fi password. I opted to use my hot spot instead.

Delirious from the lack of sleep from the night before, I went back to the Hyatt Place. To my amazement, I found guest after guest being given room keys. Like the woman before me, I skipped the queue and went to the front of the line. I asked if my room was ready. They said they would check. Indeed it was ready. I calmly asked why no one called me. I was given no response. I asked why so many people were checking in in front of me. Again, no response. I kept asking and was told that each guest’s situation is different. Unsatisfied, I calmly asked again. The woman at the front desk walked off and a man came. I reiterated my questions and was given multiple explanations: 1) Your room just became available. 2.) We were just about to call you. 3) The guest before you had checked-in the prior night so his room was available. 4) You were upgraded so your room took longer to become available.

Given how busy and chaotic the hotel was, I would have been satisfied if they told me that they had simply forgotten to call. The rude attitude towards me and towards other guests by multiple members of the staff was unwarranted as were the excuses.

I was especially annoyed with the “we upgraded you” explanation. Upon arriving, I specifically said that I didn’t need an upgrade. All I wanted was a bed so I could go to sleep before my meeting.

Too tired to argue and too incoherent to continue speaking, I took my room key and made my way to the ‘upgraded’ room. While not quite Coming to America bad, I could not help but wonder what the non-upgraded room would have been like. Here’s what I found:

a window with a light shining through
It’s only got one window, but it’s not facing a brick wall.

Bedroom

This is one of the smallest rooms I have stayed at in NYC.

a bed with white sheets and lamps in a hotel room
The room was so small that I had to make a great effort to capture the whole bed in one photo.

Upgrade? 

a tv on the wall
Were you expecting an espresso machine as part of the upgrade?

Bathroom

The bathroom was even tinier. The shower had no pressure. The water dripped on the metal drain, one droplet at a time. Think Chinese Water Torture.

a bathroom with a glass shower and sink
Don’t trip over the toilet on the way to the shower.
a shower with a towel and a hand rail
You see the metal drain? Ding, ding, ding.
a group of white bottles with black caps on a wall
At least the Hyatt Place soap is consistent.

Office Space

There was a small depressing nook where a single guest could sit and lament paying full price for this room.

a table and chair in a room
Lonely is the man who sits here.
a chair in a room
Even lonelier in black and white.

Location

While I hate Times Square and prefer to stay away from Midtown Manhattan, I must point out that this hotel is not directly located in Times Square. It is half a mile away which may be critical should you be in NYC on a cold, snowy day.

TPOL’s Tip: The address is 350 W 39th St, New York, NY 10018 

Overall

After one night, I had enough of this hotel. I went back to my old reliable choice, the Hyatt Place LIC (see It Was the Best Deal in NY).

a building with windows and cars parked on the side of the road
I will not be welcomed back, though I was never welcomed from the start.
RELATED ARTICLES

13 COMMENTS

  1. Your expectations are completely out of line for a limited/no service hotel in Times Square manhattan. I’m impressed you were able to check in before 3. Rates are that high due to the airbnb ban and other hotels being converted to migrant/homeless shelters.

    • I wish. I find people in NYC to be too nice. I’m probably the meanest guy there. The hotel staff was rude, not the transplants in the city.

  2. Regardless, the hotel made a promise and should deliver on it, be it a phone call or something else. A simple “We are busy and forgot… sorry” is easier than making a series of excuses and usually is received better. As to airbnb, shortage of hotels due to migrants, that sounds like a lot of not a hotel guest’s problem. I used to say this to my ground handling vendor: “I have as much empathy as humanly possible for your issues with finding staffing, but in the end this is why my employer has outsourced this to you, so that it isn’t my problem.” And then they learned what the malus part of bonus-malus meant in the contract. It is the hotel’s job to set and manage expectations. If it means absolutely zero early check ins, then fine, make that policy and state it so that potential guests can let that weigh in their purchase decision. I’ve seen hotels do that – fine, if I think there’s a need I might be early and want somewhere to kill time then I’ll book elsewhere.

Leave a Reply

BoardingArea